Instinct’s AI product recommendations spark user backlash

AI startup Instinct has launched Instinct Selections, a feature offering personalized product recommendations for dining, travel, and shopping. While the company emphasizes a blend of AI and human curation, some users are pushing back against unsolicited suggestions, calling them intrusive. The launch comes as Instinct approaches $1 billion in annual transactions, backed by a $10 billion valuation.

Instinct Selections: AI Meets Human Curation

Instinct, an AI startup, has launched a new feature called Instinct Selections, which delivers personalized product recommendations across dining, travel, and shopping. According to TechCrunch, the feature aims to differentiate itself by incorporating input from human experts, including chefs, designers, and travel guides, alongside AI-driven suggestions.

User Reactions: Mixed but Critical

While Instinct Selections is positioned as a tool for discovery, some users have pushed back against its unsolicited recommendations. TechCrunch reports that several users described the feature as "disappointing" or intrusive, citing instances where suggestions were delivered without explicit consent or context. This has raised concerns about user privacy and the boundaries of AI-driven personalization.

Financial Backing and Growth

Instinct’s ambitious expansion comes on the heels of a $1 billion Series C funding round, which valued the company at $10 billion. While the startup has not disclosed its user base size, it claims its platform is approaching $1 billion in annual transactions, with over 50% of activity tied to travel. Despite this growth, the revenue model for Instinct Selections remains unclear, though analysts suggest it could lend itself to advertising, commerce, or affiliate strategies.

Competitive Landscape

Instinct’s move into AI-driven commerce puts it in direct competition with tech giants like Meta and OpenAI, both of which are exploring similar features. Meta has experimented with AI-powered shopping assistants, while OpenAI has integrated third-party plugins to enable transactional capabilities within its chat interfaces. However, Instinct’s emphasis on human curation sets it apart in a crowded market.

What this means

Lazyfounder analysis — our interpretation, not reported fact.

Instinct’s launch of Instinct Selections reflects a broader trend in AI-driven commerce: leveraging personalization to drive user engagement and transactions. However, the mixed reactions to unsolicited recommendations underscore a critical challenge for AI startups—balancing utility with user consent. Founders should note that even well-intentioned personalization can backfire if it feels intrusive or disconnected from user expectations.

The involvement of human curators is a smart differentiator, as it adds a layer of trust and expertise that pure AI recommendations often lack. But the unclear revenue model for this feature raises questions about sustainability. Will Instinct lean into advertising, affiliate partnerships, or direct commerce? The answer could set a precedent for how AI assistants monetize recommendations without alienating users.

For operators, this story is a reminder that scaling AI features isn’t just about technology—it’s about understanding user psychology. Instinct’s $10 billion valuation signals investor appetite for AI-driven platforms, but long-term success will depend on aligning product design with user trust and regulatory expectations.

Key takeaways

• Instinct Selections aims to blend AI and human expertise for personalized recommendations.
• Unsolicited recommendations have led to mixed user reactions, highlighting privacy and user experience concerns.
• Instinct’s $10 billion valuation reflects investor confidence despite unclear revenue models for the new feature.
• The platform’s transaction volume is growing, with travel making up the majority of activity.
• Competitors like Meta and OpenAI are also exploring AI-driven commerce and assistant features.

FAQ

What is Instinct Selections?

Instinct Selections is a new feature from AI startup Instinct that provides personalized product recommendations for dining, travel, and shopping. It combines AI-driven suggestions with input from human experts like chefs and travel guides.

Why are some users unhappy with Instinct Selections?

Some users have criticized the feature for delivering unsolicited recommendations, which they describe as intrusive or disappointing. The lack of explicit consent for these suggestions has raised concerns about user privacy and experience.

How does Instinct plan to monetize Instinct Selections?

Instinct has not disclosed a clear revenue model for Instinct Selections. However, observers suggest it could explore advertising, commerce partnerships, or affiliate revenue streams.

How does Instinct Selections compare to competitors like Meta and OpenAI?

While Meta and OpenAI are also exploring AI-driven commerce and recommendations, Instinct differentiates itself by incorporating human curation alongside AI suggestions. This approach aims to add a layer of expertise and trust to its recommendations.

Related on Lazyfounder

• Instinct
• Meta
• OpenAI
• More ai news
• DoorDash Launches AI Agent for Food Orders via Text, Faces EU Regulatory Hurdles